It’s one of the first questions many business leaders ask when exploring public relations. After all, in most areas of business, service providers give clear projections: accountants promise compliant filings, IT teams guarantee uptime, ad agencies guarantee placements. So why do those in PR — a powerful driver of reputation, trust, and influence — resist putting outcomes in writing?
Audio: Listen to this article.
The short answer: because guaranteeing PR outcomes is misleading, often unethical, and fundamentally conflicts with how PR works.
PR is not an on-demand product or a switch you flip. It’s a discipline rooted in strategy, credibility, and relationships. Success depends on external forces we can’t control — journalists, editors, analysts, influencers, algorithms, and the news cycle itself. That’s why promises of guaranteed coverage should be a red flag when you’re evaluating PR firms.
Let’s explore why reputable PR professionals don’t (and shouldn’t) guarantee outcomes and what you can evaluate instead to see PR’s value for your organization.
Why executives crave guarantees
To be fair, the instinct is understandable.
- Procurement culture
Executives are trained to demand deliverables, KPIs, and guarantees. PR looks unusual compared to other line items. - ROI pressure
Marketing leaders are under constant scrutiny to prove impact on revenue and growth. A firm saying “We’ll get you 12 placements per quarter” feels like clarity. - Misleading competitors
Less scrupulous firms know this and exploit it, dangling coverage guarantees to win contracts.
But here’s the truth: Those “guarantees” often hide shortcuts (like paid placements disguised as earned media) or misaligned tactics that may not serve your long-term reputation.
The misconceptions behind guaranteed PR
1. “We can guarantee you media coverage”
PR is about earned media — visibility you don’t buy but win through relevance, credibility, and timing. Unlike advertising or paid media, no one can “guarantee” that a journalist will run your story. They serve their audience, not your company.
When PR firms promise coverage, they’re often:
- Talking about sponsored content (e.g., ads, advertorials, paid media, or placed media), not true news content.
- Recycling low-value press release distributions into “coverage reports.”
- Overpromising in ways that damage trust.
2. “We know the right people”
Relationships matter in PR. A strong network can get your email opened. But it won’t guarantee coverage if the story isn’t newsworthy.
Editors risk their credibility with every piece they publish. The best PR professionals know how to match a story to an outlet’s audience and build lasting trust with the client and journalist. Access opens the door; the story earns the seat.
A bridesmaid at a New York Times editor’s wedding isn’t going to get special treatment for her client's story she pitches — news outlets publish stories to serve their audiences, not friends or PR clients.
3. “We’ll deliver X number of hits, guaranteed”
Numbers sound reassuring. But chasing quotas encourages fluff. Ten meaningless mentions don’t equal one impactful story. And just as a mom-and-pop retailer in a small town won’t benefit from being in The Wall Street Journal as much as they might benefit from local media coverage, a B2B tech brand might be better off in a targeted industry trade media outlet than in a broader consumer business publication like The Wall Street Journal.
The danger of guaranteed volume is that firms may:
- Push irrelevant stories just to meet a quota.
- Prioritize low-tier outlets over high-impact opportunities.
- Inflate results with vanity metrics.
PR isn’t about filling spreadsheets with clippings; it’s about strategic visibility where it matters.
4. “We guarantee this many impressions/reach”
Firms often present impressions, advertising value equivalents, and inflated “reach” numbers as proof of success. But these are vanity metrics that are estimates, not guarantees.
Impressions don’t mean anyone read or cared about the story. A million theoretical eyeballs on an irrelevant placement are worth less than one key story reaching your buyers, investors, or regulators.
Why PR is different from marketing and advertising
Here’s the core difference: Advertising buys space; PR earns it.
Advertising guarantees an outcome because money changes hands. A 30-second spot during a football game will run, no matter how good or bad your message is.
PR is a credibility engine. Media outlets, stakeholders, and the public decide whether your message deserves attention. That third-party validation is what makes PR powerful — and impossible to guarantee.
Good PR firms embrace this. Bad ones blur the lines, equating placed media or sponsored posts with PR success.
What you can expect and measure
While ethical PR firms won’t guarantee outcomes, they should guarantee discipline, process, and accountability.
Inputs (what PR firms do)
- Research and planning
- Message development
- Media training and spokesperson preparation
- Media list building and relationship management
- Story mining and pitch development
Outputs (what you see)
- Press releases drafted and distributed
- Media pitches delivered
- Briefings secured
- Bylines and thought leadership articles placed
- Event visibility opportunities
Outcomes (what changes)
- Media coverage earned (not promised, but tracked and evaluated)
- Key messages appearing in articles
- Greater share of voice in your industry
- Positive shifts in brand reputation metrics
Impact (what matters most)
- Increased trust from stakeholders
- Stronger sales pipeline from brand credibility
- More investor confidence
- Faster crisis recovery
- Long-term reputation resilience
This layered approach (Inputs → Outputs → Outcomes → Impact) offers clarity without false promises.
Real-world examples: Why guarantees fail
- The funding announcement
A startup might expect every outlet to cover its Series A. In reality, unless the funding is unusually large or tied to a hot trend, most outlets won’t bite. PR pros know how to find the angle, but they can’t force the news cycle. - The product launch
A company wants guaranteed top-tier coverage for a product that isn’t revolutionary. Ethical firms manage expectations, focusing on trade media and customer storytelling. Unethical ones promise Forbes and fail. - The crisis
During negative news, leadership asks PR teams to “guarantee” positive counter-stories. The reality: Crisis PR can mitigate damage and rebuild trust, but it can’t erase a story already in motion.
The integrity gap in PR
At Axia Public Relations, our first core value is integrity. That means:
- We don’t promise what we can’t control.
- We don’t sell paid placements as PR.
- We don’t chase vanity metrics at the expense of strategy.
Integrity matters because PR is about trust. If your PR firm is comfortable misleading you with “guaranteed coverage,” how can you trust them to manage your company’s reputation with the media, investors, or the public?
Questions to ask before hiring a PR firm
- How do you define PR success?
- Do you offer guarantees of coverage or outcomes? (If yes, walk away.)
- How do you measure effectiveness without vanity metrics?
- How do you integrate PR strategy with overall business goals?
- What’s your process for ensuring stories align with our brand values?
- Can you share how you’ve handled situations when pitches didn’t land?
- How do you balance short-term visibility with long-term reputation?
These questions separate partners of integrity from vendors selling smoke.
Why long-term PR partnerships outperform
Another truth buyers need to hear: The best PR results compound over years, not months.
Journalists trust consistency. Executives grow into confident spokespeople. Messaging matures. Opportunities compound.
Our own data backs this: Axia clients see a 448% increase in earned media reach within their first 90 days, but the real impact comes in years three, five, and beyond. PR is about compounding trust, not quarterly quotas.
Conclusion: Guarantees don’t build trust. Integrity does.
It takes 20 years to build a reputation and five minutes to ruin it. Warren Buffett’s insight is the perfect reminder of why PR is too important to be gamified with false guarantees.
PR isn’t about flipping a switch. It’s about showing up consistently, telling the right stories, and earning credibility in ways money can’t buy.
If a firm offers you “guaranteed coverage,” they’re selling advertising, not PR. What you need is a partner who will guide you honestly, manage expectations wisely, and deliver strategies that strengthen your reputation for the long term.
That’s the promise of ethical, strategic PR. And it’s worth far more than any guarantee.
Mistakes can impact your success, so check out our e-book “15 mistakes companies make when hiring a PR firm” – don’t let hiring the wrong PR firm be one of them.
Photo by Gül Işık
Topics: earned media, news media
Comment on This Article